The concept of corporate purpose has come under increasing criticism. Largely because there is still a misunderstanding about what it is and what it’s for.
There is quite a litany of criticism: Purpose isn’t differentiating enough; purpose is too vague; purpose leads to worse performing advertising; purpose is just greenwashing, companies say one things and do another; purpose is too woolly and doesn’t mean anything; instead of purpose we should be focused on the fundamentals.
All fair comments if you are trying to use purpose as positioning and to drive advertising or you haven’t got your fundamentals in place. However, these criticisms just demonstrate that somewhere along the line ‘purpose’ has become something it wasn’t meant to be.
Purpose doesn’t replace positioning. People don’t buy from you for your purpose, they buy for their needs to be met. But,they need to trust who they buy from.
Let’s take a step back to understand why purpose emerged as important in the first place and what it actually is…
For a transaction to take place there must be an element of trust. For a longer-term relationship with multiple transactions there needs to be a higher level of trust but over 75% of consumers do not trust companies to ‘do the right thing’. Trust in a transaction can only exist if there is some element of mutuality: where we can both see that we are both getting something out of this and have a mutual interest in the other party getting what they want out of it.
In the book Trust Based Selling, Charles H Green puts forward an equation for trust: Trustworthiness = (Credibility + Reliability + Intimacy)/ Self Orientation. He applies it to human relationships, but I think it holds lessons for brands too.
The more self-orientated you are, the less trustworthy you appear to be. The more generous or other orientated you are, the more trustworthy.
We are constantly evaluating the extent to which the party we are dealing with may or may not have our best interests at heart. To what degree are they generous or self-orientated, to what extent can we trust them.
Many businesses are guilty of operating in a selfish and self-serving manner, deploying all sorts of manipulative tactics to extract value from consumers. Equally there are many who really care about providing the products and services they offer to the best of their ability and genuinely want them to have a positive impact on their customers lives, if not the broader world to some degree.
There are enough businesses that operate in the former manner to make consumers highly sceptical. So how do you make sure you operate like the latter and that customers recognise this? Well, this is where purpose comes in.
Before I continue, purpose may be poor description of the phenomenon which I’m trying to describe. It’s jargon that tries to describe the intention or motivations of an individual or organisation – it’s why. And there is a difference between having a purpose and being purposeful. Patagonia and Yeo Valley don’t have particularly well-articulated purposes, but are regarded as highly purposeful and trustworthy companies which is demonstrated by their behaviour.,
When building trust, what matters more than anything is how you behave. The choices you make arise from your true motivations and your value system.
If organisations and individuals sit on a spectrum of selfish to generous, how do you ensure you are operating in a generous enough way to be trustworthy? It’s complicated and complex, but one tool you can start with is subscribing to a purpose that articulates your contribution to the world.
By stating it in terms of contribution to the world, the purpose statement puts the onus on external impact and service. By being orientated to the world it is, necessarily, a generous statement not a selfish statement. That’s why to be the biggest, or number 1 might work well as an objective, but not a purpose.
Defining that statement is just the first step. The extremely difficult and complex part is building the process, behaviours and culture to operate in-line with that purpose. This is the bit that you can’t fake. And this is the bit that really matters.
There are plenty of examples of organisations from Facebook to Enron with great words on the wall that operate in an entirely different way to their stated purpose and values. Or others who take their purpose and run ad campaigns without actually living it. And that is why purpose comes under such criticism.
Maybe some businesses just can’t ‘be purposeful’ because their culture and world view doesn’t allow it. This is what happens when you put profit before purpose, but pretend to have a purpose anyway. It just doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.
None of this replaces positioning. It relates to the brand because how you behave will impact your reputation and trust, which are important brand metrics. But you absolutely still need to do the important work of understanding your market and building a relevant and differentiated positioning and then creating distinctive brand assets and so on.
Purpose will help brand building. But it works at a more subtle level and isn’t sufficient on its own. Think of it as theunderpinning foundation to the shining tower that is your brand.
People will be attracted to what you offer them. People will choose you when you give them something nobody else can. That is your differentiated brand positioning working for you. A strong brand should impact trial and purchase intent metrics. If you have done a good job of implementing your purpose and built a trustworthy organisation then you should see strong loyalty and recommendation metrics.
Purpose has become the purview of brand consultants and ad agencies because we have the tools to uncover and manage big ideas. But what really matters is the activation of purpose and often we are excluded from those conversations.
In a way we’ve made things worse because there is so much ‘purpose’ washing that it has become noise and is now even harder for consumers to find their way to a brand they trust and that meets their needs.
At the end of the day, it comes to down to your intention. Are you trying to take as much as you can, or contribute as much as you can? You will be trusted accordingly.

