View Post

Purpose is misunderstood and maligned– but I’m doubling down. 

The concept of corporate purpose has come under increasing criticism. Largely because there is still a misunderstanding about what it is and what it’s for.  

There is quite a litany of criticism: Purpose isn’t differentiating enough; purpose is too vague; purpose leads to worse performing advertising; purpose is just greenwashing, companies say one things and do another; purpose is  too woolly and doesn’t mean anything; instead of purpose we should be focused on the fundamentals. 

All fair comments if you are trying to use purpose as positioning and to drive advertising or you haven’t got your fundamentals in place. However, these criticisms just demonstrate that somewhere along the line ‘purpose’ has become something it wasn’t meant to be. 

Purpose doesn’t replace positioning. People don’t buy from you for your purpose, they buy for their needs to be met. But,they need to trust who they buy from. 

Let’s take a step back to understand why purpose emerged as important in the first place and what it actually is…

For a transaction to take place there must be an element of trust. For a longer-term relationship with multiple transactions there needs to be a higher level of trust but over 75% of consumers do not trust companies to ‘do the right thing’. Trust in a transaction can only exist if there is some element of mutuality: where we can both see that we are both getting something out of this and have a mutual interest in the other party getting what they want out of it.

In the book Trust Based Selling, Charles H Green puts forward an equation for trust: Trustworthiness = (Credibility + Reliability + Intimacy)/ Self Orientation. He applies it to human relationships, but I think it holds lessons for brands too.

The more self-orientated you are, the less trustworthy you appear to be. The more generous or other orientated you are, the more trustworthy.

We are constantly evaluating the extent to which the party we are dealing with may or may not have our best interests at heart. To what degree are they generous or self-orientated, to what extent can we trust them. 

Many businesses are guilty of operating in a selfish and self-serving manner, deploying all sorts of manipulative tactics to extract value from consumers. Equally there are many who really care about providing the products and services they offer to the best of their ability and genuinely want them to have a positive impact on their customers lives, if not the broader world to some degree.

There are enough businesses that operate in the former manner to make consumers highly sceptical. So how do you make sure you operate like the latter and that customers recognise this? Well, this is where purpose comes in.

Before I continue, purpose may be poor description of the phenomenon, which I’m trying to describe. It’s jargon that tries to describe the intention or motivations of an individual or organisation – it’s why. And there is a difference between having a purpose and being purposeful. Patagonia and Yeo Valley don’t have particularly well-articulated purposes, but are regarded as highly purposeful and trustworthy companies which is demonstrated by their behaviour.

When building trust, what matters more than anything is how you behave. The choices you make arise from your true motivations and your value system.

If organisations and individuals sit on a spectrum of selfish to generous, how do you ensure you are operating in a generous enough way to be trustworthy? It’s complicated and complex, but one tool you can start with is subscribing to a purpose that articulates your contribution to the world.

By stating it in terms of contribution to the world, the purpose statement puts the onus on external impact and service. By being orientated to the world it is, necessarily, a generous statement not a selfish statement. That’s why to be the biggest, or number 1 might work well as an objective, but not a purpose.

Defining that statement is just the first step. The extremely difficult and complex part is building the process, behaviours and culture to operate in-line with that purpose. This is the bit that you can’t fake. And this is the bit that really matters. 

There are plenty of examples of organisations from Facebook to Enron with great words on the wall that operate in an entirely different way to their stated purpose and values. Or others who take their purpose and run ad campaigns without actually living it. And that is why purpose comes under such criticism.

Maybe some businesses just can’t ‘be purposeful’ because their culture and world view doesn’t allow it. This is what happens when you put profit before purpose, but pretend to have a purpose anyway. It just doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

None of this replaces positioning. It relates to the brand because how you behave will impact your reputation and trust, which are important brand metrics. But you absolutely still need to do the important work of understanding your market and building a relevant and differentiated positioning and then creating distinctive brand assets and so on.

Purpose will help brand building. But it works at a more subtle level and isn’t sufficient on its own. Think of it as theunderpinning foundation to the shining tower that is your brand.

People will be attracted to what you offer them. People will choose you when you give them something nobody else can. That is your differentiated brand positioning working for you. A strong brand should impact trial and purchase intent metrics. If you have done a good job of implementing your purpose and built a trustworthy organisation then you should see strong loyalty and recommendation metrics. 

Purpose has become the purview of brand consultants and ad agencies because we have the tools to uncover and manage big ideas. But what really matters is the activation of purpose and often we are excluded from those conversations. 

In a way we’ve made things worse because there is so much ‘purpose’ washing that it has become noise and is now even harder for consumers to find their way to a brand they trust and that meets their needs. 

At the end of the day, it comes to down to your intention. Are you trying to take as much as you can, or contribute as much as you can? You will be trusted accordingly. 

View Post

I can’t stand all that fluffy stuff! What most leaders get wrong about brand.

Too many business leaders shy away from doing this one vital thing to build strong brands, and it’s not what you might think. As a result, they risk stagnant growth, declining market share and costly failed marketing campaigns. 

70% of business value is intangible

People buy for emotional reasons. Strong brands connect with people’s emotions and that is what drives the numbers. 1Only 30% of the value of the world’s top 10,000 companies is represented by the tangible assets on their balance sheets. The remaining 70% is intangible value, such as intellectual property, and how customers, employees and stakeholder feel about them.

However, for many businesspeople, engaging in the ‘fluffy stuff’ isn’t at all appealing, they smirk and chuckle or shift in their seats when it comes time to discuss the brand. 

It’s understandable. Business culture emphasises being rational, strategic, ordered, systematic and measurable. That is all valid, but it’s only half the equation. 

Harvard Business School professor Gerald Zaltman says that 95 percent of our purchase decision making takes place in the subconscious mind. The subconscious runs on emotion.

Which is why the most loved brands and profitable businesses know how to effectively harness both emotional and rational thinking. 

Navigating emotion is a critical skill

It’s a fundamental business skill. But because some people find it uncomfortable, they haven’t developed the tools to navigate it. Or maybe that’s why they feel uncomfortable. Either way they are missing out on some of the most powerful profit drivers available. 

The good news is that anyone can learn how to effectively combine rational and emotional thinking to get incredible results. And it’s the synergy between the two which is unbeatable. The rational brings the focus, the emotion brings the power. 

Focused by logic, powered by emotion.

Whether you have a new idea or a new campaign you want to launch, the fundamentals are the same. 

You first need to make a series of rational decisions about what market opportunity you are pursuing, who are you targeting, what are you offering them, how are you going to differentiate from competition, what strengths or advantages you are going to leverage and build, and so on. 

You are starting to create the rational framework about where to focus. But now you also need to build the emotional connection that will fuel your brand. 

Your success comes down to your ability to understand the emotional needs and desires of your audience and to build a story which creates an emotional impact. 

The challenge can be made simpler by tackling it from both ends:

One, use the right tools and processes to reduce the ambiguity and ‘fluffyness’ of the emotions you are trying to map, and two, develop the ability to tune into and relate to those emotions so you know how to harness them.

Developing Your Emotional Intelligence

The more you understand the drivers behind the behaviour of your customers, the more powerfully you can create connections with them. 

We all have feelings, developing emotional intelligence so we can navigate those feelings and use them to help us connect with others is skill that can be learned.

  • Become insatiably curious and observe people closely. 
  • Listen for the change in someone’s voice and body language when they touch on something meaningful to them. 
  • Learn to identify insights that are not just interesting, but are deep human truths. 
  • Learn to relate words, ideas, visuals, stories back to the insights you heard from listening to you customers. 
  • Learn to notice when an idea is a ‘big idea’ and rooted in a fundamental human truth. 
  • Learn to categorise different ideas and know how to put everything in its right place. Eg the difference between a benefit, a feature and a purpose. 
  • Learn how to look for that golden thread that connects ideas at different levels. 

This can all be taught. Certain categories are emotional battlegrounds and great for developing these talents. Shifts in emotional perceptions of a few percentage points can translate to millions of pounds of revenue lost and gained in categories like laundry. As a result FMCG marketers have honed their skill of relating this emotional understanding to results, but it can be learned by almost everyone. 

Reducing Risk

If however you aren’t yet confident in your or your organisation’s ability to effectively navigate those emotional territories; there are a multitude of experienced professionals, tools and methodologies to help you manage the ambiguity.

Insights researchers know how deploy the right tools and techniques to not only uncover deep emotional insights, but also how to model, compare and quantify different propositions to give brand owners confidence about the right direction to take. 

From traditional focus groups, interviews and concept testing to creative exploration workshops and adcept testing there are many tools available. 

Brand strategists draw on psychology, neuroscience, bench mark studies, consumer research and creative story telling to craft brands that are enduring, compelling and solid bedrocks for growth. 

They know how to evoke positive emotions through their effective use of their values, purpose, or value-driven storytelling can develop a strong emotional connection with consumers. Critically they they are adept at helping clients navigate decisions, reducing risk and connecting those emotions to the bottom line. 

All it takes is a little bit of appreciation of and a willingness to lean into the ‘fluffy stuff’ to get the best out of them. They already know the importance of rigour and data in decision making and how important it is to you. 

Impacting the organisation

But the synergy of emotion and logic doesn’t stop there. Its not enough to define a brand, it needs to be effectively expressed across an organisation, across touch points and over time. 

Great rebrands often are very effective at engaging, inspiring and galvanising internal teams. A recent piece of work for an international sporting championship catalysed a shift in the culture across the organisation. Teams who had previously seen the brand team as ‘the colouring in department’ and the brand as the logo are now coming to the client team with ideas about how they can bring the brand to life in their work. 

Communicating the brand story precipitated a surge in pride, understanding and motivation because it helped everyone understand on an emotional level why what they did was important, as well as what they stood for and delivered to fans. 

At the same time changes to the business process were put in place to ensure effective internal communication of the brand; training in how to brief and assess brand implantation; and reviews and measures to assess and optimise the impact of the brand – including leading and lagging measures to tie emotional brand and commercial metrics together. 

Get Effective

Is your growth where you want to it be? If not its worth taking some time to consider how effective your organisation is at using both rational and emotional thinking? 

Could you know your customers better? Could you be clearer about the benefits you bring your audience. Is your purpose bringing people together? Does everyone know why they are there? Ask your people what they think and maybe get an outside perspective. 

But if all you do is get curious, listen more and don’t be afraid to sit forward in your seat when it comes to the ‘fluffy stuff’ then you will be ahead of most.  

1

  1. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/intangible-value-70-global-economy-jonathan-knowles/ ↩︎
View Post

Purpose – The Hidden Advantage Startups Have Over Bigger Competitors

Startups have a hidden unfair advantage that can be a powerful weapon against big incumbents. And it doesn’t have anything to do with being nimble.

Every business begins with someone trying to make something better. Someone somewhere said, there is a problem and we can fix that. Maybe it was a new problem. Maybe it was a problem that someone else was already addressing but not doing a great job. Or maybe it was something ubiquitous that we have always needed. At its core was an intention to improve life somehow. And a belief that the only way things were going to get better is if they did it. A belief so intense that a business was born. This is a kind of madness. A madness that has beauty and power in it.

Purpose is one the greatest motivators of human behaviour. Give people the right purpose and they will follow you, trust you, live and die for you. In business, it acts as this subtle but profound force that attracts people to you. People who want to help you, people who want to join you, support you and buy from you. What business doesn’t want customers, employees and investors flocking to get involved?

Some say that the business of business is making money. But if you aren’t helping someone solve a problem – then you are not creating value. The business of business is helping people. Profits are a function of that help.

“The greatest businesses hold onto their original purpose. They make it an integral part of their culture and identity”.

Too many businesses lose touch with their original purpose. As they grow the business becomes less about the original intent and more about profit, and processes. Profits and processes are critical – but in service of something greater. Because profits and processes are tangible and measurable they become the focus. They become the master that we serve not the original intent behind the business. The greatest businesses hold onto their original purpose. They make it an integral part of their culture and identity. These are the businesses that we love and are loyal to. That we buy from again and again. That we recommend to our friends. That everyone wants to work for.

The advantage for startups is that the original idea is fresh. The idea that had the power to bring they organisation to life in the first place, is still present. It is raw, recent, real. And customers can smell that.

In bigger businesses, it goes stale. It gets diluted. Which is why we find it easier to connect with smaller businesses – they feel more human. More trustworthy. And that is because of the presence of purpose. Bigger businesses will always have to work harder to convince you that their intentions are genuine. Smaller businesses can just feel easier to connect with.
There has never been a better time to start a business. The barriers to entry are plummeting. Access to talent, technology and markets is easier and cheaper than ever before. What not everyone realises is that access to trust is also easier than it ever was. In the age of social media, that trust can get amplified and gain you attention, at the speed of the internet.

So don’t lose sight of your purpose. Identify it, manage it, protect it, use it. It is one of your most cherished and powerful assets. And although it didn’t cost you anything. Losing sight of it might cost you a fortune.

 

View Post

Brand Trust Is Still Important For Tech Brands. Even Facebook

Brand plays a bigger or lesser role in different categories. People buy and use products and services for a basket of reasons, but choice and preference is primarily driven by some form of differentiation. In a market with a lot of product parity brand differentiation is critical. Consider bottled water, with very little functional difference between products creating a differentiated brand proposition is vital to drive consumer choice in your direction.

In other categories brand plays less of role because other factors are given more consideration. For example with prescription medicines purchasing and prescription decisions are supposed to be made solely on clinical data, brand should theoretically play a very limited role.

So what about tech companies? How important is brand to them? It is very easy to fall into the trap of ignoring brand and relying on the functionality and utility of the technology. Take Facebook, you might argue that it really doesn’t matter what you think of the brand because the utility of having your friends and family on one site is so important it transcends any benefits brought by having a brand that I can trust and engage with.

Now in terms of choice this is true, where else would I go to get the status updates of all my nearest and dearest? But brand plays a very important role in lots of different types of behaviour, not just choice between two products. Having a trusted brand can also influence technology adoption, loyalty and usage.

We see this playing out with backlash against the planned upgrade of Facebook’s mobile app to include ambient listening technology.  There is already a petition with over 250,000 signatures asking Facebook to not release the update. In fact I heard about the petition before I heard about the update.

The Facebook brand doesn’t have a good reputation for respecting privacy. You could argue one of the things it stands for in the minds of many users is “privacy violator” and that affects our behaviour. It affects how often we post, what we post and now it is affecting our willingness to adopt new features and technologies.

Of course Facebook insist that the upgrade is there to help us, and maybe it would be wonderful to live in a world where our phone is listening in to what is going on and able to somehow make our lives easier. To give over that amount of data and control requires trust. Trust that Facebook does not have because it hasn’t managed it’s brand properly.

Our perceptions of brands are massively affected by what they do, not just what the say and look like. No matter what you are doing you have brand. Whether or not you chose to manage it or not is up to you. The 2 big lessons from this are:

1) How you define, express and manage your technology brand can affect adoption, loyalty, usage and advocacy
2) Everything you do affects perception of your brand, so make sure you live by a strong purpose and set of values.

View Post

The Power of Purpose

When I was at P&G I was involved in a course that taught coaching and NLP techniques to managers.  I had the opportunity to watch people ask themselves, sometimes for the first time, what really mattered to them. As we went through exercises that explored their values, their beliefs and ultimately their purpose I was astounded at the huge amount of positive energy created just by becoming aware of ones own inner drivers.

Over time I’ve come to believe that a strong sense of our own purpose, of the unique gift we have to give to the world is one of the most powerful things we can connect with. When we work inline with that purpose we are at our absolute best. We feel energised, motivated and creative, everything just clicks, everything just flows. What’s more when a purpose is honestly and authentically articulated it always has a net positive benefit. We feel our most alive, our most empowered when we are self actualising, when we are giving something back. Someone working inline with their purpose is normally adding to the world in someway.

What does that purpose have to do with brands?

Everything! Organisations, like people, can benefit hugely from having a clearly defined purpose.

Internally

That same sense of internal turmoil that exists within us when we don’t know what our purpose is exists within companies. A clear direction and a clear set of values allows employees to understand if the organisations purpose and values is inline with their own. Employees that feel they can do meaningful work that is important to them and inline with their purpose will be loyal, motivated and high performing. Employees that don’t feel a shared sense of purpose will be disgruntled, distracted and will probably drift away.

[quote]”The older I get, the more I see how much motivations matter. The Zune was crappy because the people at Microsoft don’t really love music or art the way we do. We won because we personally lvoe music. We made the iPod for ourselves, and when you are doing something for yourself, or your best friend or family,  you’re not going to cheese out. If you don’t love something, you’re not going to go the extra mile, work the extra weekend, challenge the status quo as much” [/quote]  Steve Jobs

Externally

When building relationships with people we might ask What someone does, but only once we dig a little deeper and understand How (driven by their values) and Why (driven by their purpose) someone does what they do are we able to truely understand them and relate to them. Understanding the Why that drives someone helps us build a connection and trust them.

We use the same framework when judging how much we can trust a company. If we can relate to an organisation on a more human level, if we can get a sense of what drives the company and what its values are we have a basis for a trusting relationship.

Simon Sinek argues that the being in touch with Why is the reason for the success of brands such as Apple.

It goes with out saying that articulating a company’s purpose is meaningless if it isn’t consistently and passionately delivered on in everything the company does.

Image by Lara Coles 

 

View Post

Eat thyself. Before someone else does.

If you want to innovate and create new value you need to be prepared to cannibalise your own business. If you don’t someone else will.

Established businesses put a lot of focus on protecting the markets and products they have created. But the pace of change is accelerating exponentially. The advantages of size and scale are diminishing as barriers to entry drop and new technologies and business models disrupt markets and kick out old players.  A mindset of protecting what you have, instead of always looking to create new value can leave you more exposed. Not taking enough risk, ironically, is becoming a very risky strategy.

At a time when the iPod was one of the best selling Apple products of all time, and represented half of the company’s revenue Steve Jobs was very worried. He knew that a phone with a strong music player could threaten their success. So he set Apple on a path to create one, even if it would eat into iPod sales – and so the iPhone was born.

That willingness to cannibalise their existing business before someone else did is one of the reasons Apple has led the pace of innovation in the way that it has.

Imagine what would have happened if Steve had decided to pull out all the stops to protect the iPod instead. Someone would have eventually launched an iPhone equivalent and we might be referring to Apple in same breath as Kodak.

Let’s hear it in Steve’s own words:

I have my own theory about why decline happens at companies like IBM or Microsoft. They company does a great job, innovates and becomes a monopoly or close to it in some field, and then the quality of the company becomes less important. The compant starts valuing the great salesmen, because they’re the ones who can move the needle on the revenues, not the product engineers and designers. So the salespeople end up running the company. John Akers at IBM was a smart, eloquent fantastic salesperson, but he didn’t know anything about product. They same thing happened at Xerox. When the sales guys run the company the product guys don’t matter so much, and a lot of them just turn off.

 

My passion has been to build an enduring company where people were motivated to make great products. Everything else was secondary. Sure it was great to make a profit, because that was what allowed you to make great products. But the products, not the profits were the motivation. Scully flipped these priorities to where the goal was to make money. It’s a subtle difference, but it ends up meaning everything: the people you hire, who gets promoted, what gets discussed at meetings.

When you shift to protecting the status quo it’s because you are serving yourselves instead of others. Stay focused on your purpose, never stop working towards it and you will never stop innovating. – Steve Jobs

Steve puts it in terms of product focus vs sales focus but the point is the same.   If you are obsessed with protecting what you have over innovation and new growth you are a target for someone to eat your lunch.